23: Dear H.H. Holmes, Part 1: The Forgotten November Tragedy

The chill of November 1888 in Chicago still whispers the unsolved mystery of a young woman's demise, a potential prelude to the ghastly tapestry of H.H. Holmes' serial murders. In this episode of Hometown History, Shane embarks on a historical investigation into the cold case of a lady whose lifeless form was discovered in the murky waters, her throat cruelly slit.

This ill-fated soul's story was lost in the shadows of time, her death overshadowed by the morbid allure of Holmes' infamous killing spree. As her remains were solemnly returned to Wabash County, Indiana, her narrative faded from public memory. Now, we resurrect her tale, retracing the steps that may link her to the notorious H.H. Holmes. Could she indeed be his first Chicago victim?

We peel back the layers of history, seeking truths that may lie hidden beneath the surface.

This gripping recount aims to shed light on a tragedy long overlooked, inviting listeners to join the search for answers in a prelude to the upcoming series on the Foul Play podcast. Dive into the depths of this historical enigma with us at ⁠itshometownhistory.com.